The following contains excerpts from the book, Twentieth Century Counterpoint (Humphrey Searle).
This book surveys serious compositions in the 20th Century, showing the development of chromatic counterpoint, expanded diatonicism, polytonality, diatonicized chomaticism, and twelve-tone composition by studying the works of Stravinsky, Hindmith, Bartok, Milhaud, and Schoenberg. It summarizes the trends through the 20th Century towards linear (melodic) writing as opposed to vertical (harmonic) writing. In a broad historical analysis of Western art music, the author makes an observation that the music written in an historic era of general peacefulness (politically, socially, etc.) the compositional writing tends towards harmonic ideas, while on the other hand the music written during an era of social upheaval tends towards linear (or melodic-based) writing.
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach our students the above concepts.
In studying Stravinsky, the author shows that throughout his work, he consistently used a diatonic system, even though within that system, he introduced many other elements that were not common to that system. He used many ostinato figures, chords moving in parallel, as well as being used as a linear motion against other linear moving parts. Many times his linear parts would move freely against each other within the diatonic scale.
We encourage students at our music school in Dallas, Texas to study Stravinsky’s influence.
Milhaud practiced polytonality, in which the composition is written in two or more keys simultaneously. Stravinsky and Bartok used this technique occasionally, but Milhaud exploited this concept in many of his works. The author concludes that even though several simultaneous keys are being used, the perception of the listener is one of hearing “constant enharmonic modulation” finally perceiving a tonal center. Milhaud was also fond of using mathematical and palindrome-like patterns.
Bartok, while adept at both kinds of writing (linear and harmonic) also made use of strong percussive or rhythmic effects. His works were so highly chromatic that they verged upon serialism, yet they still have a sense of key. It could best be described as fluctuating tonality. Bartok made tonality more ‘fluid’ in that while upholding the supremacy of a tonal center, he would combine this with the free use of all the twelve notes of the chromatic scale, also using scales derived from Hungarian folk music.
Composition students at our music school in Dallas, Texas learn Serialism and Chromaticism and how to use these in their own works.
Hindemith attempted in his own theoretical book on modern compositional techniques to resolve the dilemma of how to use all twelve notes of a chromatic scale in a logical harmonic sequence, starting with the harmonic series as the foundation of his theory. Hindemith saw notes that were derived from the beginning of the overtone series to be primarily harmonic, while notes derived from the upper end of the harmonic series more melodic. He believed that the traditional approach to music theory was irrelevant based on the following: 1) The concept that chords can be constructed by the superimposition of thirds cannot explain many chords, 2) Chords cannot now be considered invertible, 3) The concept of ‘altered chords’ is out of date and does not relate to a diatonic system, and 4) The same chord could bear various interpretations in the old system according to the key it was related to; it is illogical to continue this practice. Hindemith views the bass part as the most decisive for the development of the harmony. He states that ‘harmonic tension’ is derived from the emphasis on their relationship to the fundamental frequency of the harmonic series.
The value of understanding the overtone series cannot be overstated, and students at our music school in Dallas, Texas study how to apply it in modern composition and performance.
Schoenberg developed a system so controversial in 1908 that it has possibly been written about more than any other, both ‘for’ and ‘against’. He traced the development of ‘extended tonality’ and discussed what he called the “emancipation of the dissonance.” “One no longer expected preparations of Wagner’s dissonances or resolutions of Strauss’ discords; one was not disturbed by Debussy’s non-functional harmonies, or by the harsh counterpoint of later composers. This state of affairs led to a freer use of dissonances…” In his book “Harmonielehre”, Shoenberg suggests that the ear was less intimately acquainted with dissonant notes than with consonant ones because the former appeared later in the harmonic series. Hindemith believed that “tonality is a natural force, like gravity.” Schoenberg, however, took an opposite view.
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we help students understand the aforementioned argument as two ends of one comprehensive understanding. We show them how these things can co-exist successfully.
Other composers who stemmed from Schoenberg’s school of thought were Webern, Berg and Krenek.
There were several other well-respected composers who did not fall in line with any of the above theoretical developments. One was Szymanowshi, who was a contrapontalist interested in combining the influence of Debussyan impressionism with a modern contrapuntal technique. Another was Janacek, basing his style chiefly on continuous repetition of short, simple phrases, coupled with striking and unusual effects. Varese was one of the earliest known composers to have been involved in the development of electronic music experiments, always being more interested in the nature of sound for its own sake, never bound by any academic formula.
We teach the complexities of music theory to students at our music school in Dallas, Texas from a wholistic viewpoint, making the complex more understandable.
The author concludes: “We are thus confronted simultaneously with a breakdown of harmony and an ever-increasing complication of surface texture. And an even more serious consequence of the breakdown of harmony is that it undermines the foundations of the musical structures which were based on the diatonic scale- the sonata form, rondo, fugue, etc. All these were based on the contrast between a main tonality and its nearer or remoter neighbors; if tonality is removed, how can one continue to use the form?” He then offers his own thoughts on a possible system of theory, endeavoring to combine the various streams of thought given above.
The system of music that is popular in America, compared to the above discussion, is almost like comparing the curriculum of a preschooler to a Harvard graduate. Nevertheless, much of what we participate with in current pop-culture was at one time emerging and controversial. I would venture to say that much of what we consider ‘normal’ in today’s pop-culture was newly birthed in Europe’s 16th Century, in combination with the African influence rhythmically. The concepts discussed above are developments which may well become prevalent in contemporary culture when it is ready. It may take a while, though.