The following contains excerpts from the book, Thinking About Music (Ross Lee Finney).
Ross Lee Finney (1906-1997) was an American composer born in Wells, Minnesota who taught for many years at the University of Michigan. He studied with Nadia Boulanger, Edward Burlingame Hill, Alban Berg and Roger Sessions.
“Thinking About Music” is a collection of his writings and thoughts about a wide range of subjects pertaining to the modern composer, including the composer’s role in the university, in society in general, the creative process, and about his own unique compositional theories.
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we encourage our students to study modern composers and their thoughts and ideologies, like Finney’s.
He asserts that music has a spiritual aspect to it that differs from other learned subjects which can be studied from a scientific point of view. He correlates “the humanities” to spirit expression, opposed to scientific analysis:
“There is too much talk of the university as the patron of the arts. The creative artist in America does not ask for patronage. He seeks to contribute to that spiritual element of our culture without which we are doomed. He seeks to help correct the imbalance which materialism has inflicted upon us…he seeks to assert…that the humanities are a vibrant heritage, one that can affect our lives as profoundly as science.”
Finney, however, acknowledges that a certain balance of science and analysis in music is healthy to counterbalance creativity, agreeing with Stravinsky’s thoughts, that the “the creator’s function is to sift the elements he receives,…for human activity must impose limits upon itself. The more art is controlled, limited, worked over, the more it is free.”
His concern about music was that it not be seen in a materialistic fashion, relating an interview with the famous English composer, Ralph Vaughan Williams:
“When his picture appeared next day on the front page, underneath was the caption: “Composer Says Music Isn’t Worth Anything.” I was taken aback when I read this caption for it distorted so completely Vaughan Williams’ meaning. He had said that the values of music were not materialistic, that music could not and should not be valued in dollars and cents.”
We hope to help students at our music school in Dallas, Texas appreciate the value of the intangibles in life, music, and the arts.
“John Locke, the rationalist of the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, limited his interest to those qualities of music that were obvious and easily proved…Locke’s view was much narrower than the ideas about music that St. Augustine expressed in the fourth century. The classic ideas of Plato and Plotinus were reflected in the writings of that theologian…St. Augustine writes, “It is an image of a higher order which we are permitted to perceive if we proceed one step further to the sixth degree on our scale of musical assimilation: if we put our enjoyment of such knowledge…into the side of the balance that tends towards the order of the heavens and towards the unification of our soul with the divine principle.”
Finney quotes philosopher Ernst Cassirer, “when the scientist describes an object he characterizes it by a set of numbers, by its physical and chemical constants. Art has not only a different aim but a different object…Our aesthetic perception exhibits a much greater variety and belongs to a much more complex order than our ordinary sense perception…Aesthetic experience…is pregnant with infinite possibilities which remain unrealized in ordinary sense experience. In the work of the artist these possibilities become actualities; that are brought into the open and take on a definite shape…The imagination of the artist does not arbitrarily invent the forms of things. It shows us these forms in their true shape, making them visible and recognizable.”
It is our goal, at our music school in Dallas, Texas, to expose students to the aesthetic side of life, through their immersion into music.
Finney summarizes these thoughts, “The composer does not project his personal emotional experiences so much as he does the patterns and shapes of general emotional experience- the substratum of feeling. He evolves a symbolic ‘language’ that is a semblance of emotion.”
He gets amazingly close to discussing spiritual issues by saying, “The artist is no more in need of time to work than the scientist, nor is the scientist as an individual free from personal emotional strains. Indeed, I am certain that creative inspiration comes as mysteriously from the subconscious mind in scientists as it does in artists.”
Regarding education, he has much to say about the modern university’s role in developing the composer. As he was a professor in a university for much of his career, he takes a slightly critical tone. He cautioned that, “The composer’s emphasis upon the intuitive, the individual, and the spontaneous fills students and colleagues, who may feel themselves to be uncreative, with a certain amount of fear. This gets mixed up with the popular myth of the artist as unstable. It develops into an opposition to new ideas…I dread the tendency to tame the composer into a school-broken pet. Conformity is not the object of art in a free society and not the object of art in our schools.”
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we see a profound lack of appreciation in the way most education treats the understanding of music and the arts, which is why we exist.
He continues, “The artist often views his function in the university as that of entertainer, not even entertainer on a national scale, but merely local. And he teaches his students to be entertainers, knowing full well how few ever will succeed. The young creative artist rebels against this attitude. He realizes that art is entertainment, that it is even big business, but he knows that it is much more than that. He deplores the apathy of audiences, the lack of skill or enthusiasm of performers, and the ignorance of the administration as to the place of art in the institution…He rebels, therefore, against the historical wisdom of the university…so during the recent past the artist has moved to the fringes of the university, within its shadow but not quite part of it…Rebellion, if it is to result in a style, must be constructive, not destructive. It must lead the artist to a positive conviction, not a negative one. The student artist must be concerned with the realities of his art, realities that he can experience and judge, that he can master and control because they are meaningful to him and to his vision of life. Only in this way can each new generation find its unique relationship to tradition.”
Regarding the role of the composer and his relationship with the performer, Finney cautions the composer to write ‘communicative’ music, “not as popular music but as serious and strong music.” He encourages the composer to have a positive relationship with his local musical culture of performers.
We also encourage composers in our music school in Dallas, Texas to develop strong ties with the local musical culture.
“The architect and the commercial designer are taught that form is the result of function plus means. This formula makes a good deal of sense.”
“The arts, chief among the humanities, are concerned with the human need to dream beyond the material world and through symbols to create worlds in unreality.” He quotes Lewis Mumford, “Almost all meaning above the animal level of response comes through abstraction and symbolic reference…Without constant reference to essences, as represented by symbols, existence would become empty, meaningless, and absurd.”
It is with the metaphoric view of meaningful communication that we hope to inspire in the lives of students in our music school in Dallas, Texas the appreciation for the intrinsic value of the non-material.