The Effect of Temperature on the Tuning Standards of Wind Instruments

The following contains excerpts from the book, The Effect of Temperature on the Tuning Standards of Wind Instruments (Hall, Kent).

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we help students gain an understanding of arranging and orchestration by studying various orchestral instruments.

In this book, the authors endeavor to create a ‘tuning standard’ for wind instruments so that some kind of consistency can be achieved in wide-spread performance venues for these instruments.

Starting with a history of tuning standards, they state that, “In 1939 an International Tuning Standard of A=440 cycles per second at 72 degrees Fahrenheit was adapted.”  They subsequently try to answer the questions as to how to tune when the weather is hot or cold, bringing to light some of the effects of temperature on the performance of different instruments.

They show that throughout music history, the tuning standards for the note “A” have changed.  In 1500 A.D. a standard of A=505.8 cycles per second existed.  It became gradually lowered, and by 1700 A.D. the note “A” was equivalent to 393.2 cycles per second.  During the “classical” period “A” varied from 415 to 429 cps.  This period included the years when such people as Purcell, Bach, Handel, Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, Weber, and Shubert lived and wrote.

The history of tuning standards and tuning systems are a fascinating historical study we help students at our music school in Dallas, Texas appreciate, as part of their musical education.

During the 19th Century, as the orchestra assumed greater importance, wind instruments were developed and improved.  One method of producing more exciting effects was to raise the pitch of the sounds.  By the end of the century some bands were playing at a tuning of A=457 cps, and during the first years of the 20th Century, manufacturers produced both “low-pitched’ instruments at A=440 cps and “high-pitched instruments” at approximately A=457 cps.  At times both kinds of instruments were inadvertently used in the same band with rather peculiar results.

Throughout the 19th Century, there were many who deplored the lack of a tuning standard, and as early as 1834 a “Congress of Physicists” held a Stuttgart adopted a proposal to fix the A at 440 cps.  In 1858 the French Government appointed a commission of musicians and physicists, who in 1859 recommended a fixed standard of A=435.  In 1896, England adopted A=439 cps at 68 degrees F. or A=435 cps at 59 degrees F.  In 1909 the tuning standard for military bands in England was defined as A=452 at 60 degrees F.  In 1918 the American Federation of Musicians adopted A=440 cps as the standard tuning frequency.  In 1925, the Musical Industries Chamber of Commerce adopted A=440 cps and the American Standard Association adopted the same standard in 1936.  Finally, in 1939, and international adoption of A=440 cps at 72 degrees F. was made.

In order to construct wind instruments successfully, having an agreed upon tuning standard was highly beneficial, since having the performer make adjustments in their playing technique, or by making minor adjustments to their instruments, to accommodate for the intonation differences was ultimately not very successful.

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we hold to the tuning standard of A = 440, sometimes 442 in stringed instrument tuning, for the sake of brightness in performance.

Tuning is directly affected by temperature, since, in wind instruments the speed of sound in air changes with temperature.  Wind instruments become sharper if the speed of sound is faster, and they become flatter if it is slower.  Since the speed of sound increases with higher temperatures, the sound then goes through the instrument faster, and the instrument is sharper, because, effectively, it is shorter.  On the other hand, mallet-played instruments tend to become slightly flatter with change of temperature because of the expansion of the bar material with higher temperatures.   

With all of these variables, the musician’s one constant foundation is the attentive musical ear.  At our music school in Dallas, Texas we help students develop the ability to listen critically to intonation and tuning.

Wind instruments are sensitive to two temperature influences: that of the environment, or external temperature, and that of the player’s breath.  The temperature inside the instrument, the internal temperature, lies somewhere between that of the breath and that of the environment.  In laboratory experiments, at temperatures less than 80 degrees, fifteen to twenty minutes of playing a brass or woodwind instrument has been necessary in order to stabilize intonation.  If the external temperature varies, the instruments should be checked fairly often and readjusted.  A rise in temperature, which is common during a performance on the concert stage, may cause the instruments to become sharp, which in turn tends to cause all other non-wind instruments in the organization to adjust “toward the sharp side,” with consequent intonation problems.  Hot stage lights can intensify this problem.

Another difficulty lies in the fact that each different kind of wind instrument changes pitch at different rates when external temperature changes happen.  A general ‘rule of thumb’, however, that can be applied across the board is: “The frequency of the tuning standard may be permitted to rise approximately one double vibration (cycle) for each ten degrees rise in temperature.”  This approximation, A=440 cps at 72 degrees F., 441 at 80 degrees F. (+4 cents), 442 at 90 degrees F. (+8 cents), and 443 at 100 degrees F. (+12 cents) will come close to following the rise of most wind instruments.

Stringed instruments have a similar response to temperature, and the player must constantly be aware of adjustments during performance.  The mature player will lean to his internal ear to make those adjustments throughout these changes that can happen.  At our music school in Dallas, Texas we place an emphasis on developing this internal musical memory of pitch and intonation.

In summary, the director may allow the tuning standard to move sharp enough at higher temperatures to permit the wind instruments to have satisfactory internal intonation.  In this case he must “live with” the discrepancy between the winds and non-winds.  On the other hand he can remedy the wind/non-wind discrepancy and maintain approximately an A=440 standard regardless of temperature.  In that even the must “live with” the resulting problems of internal tuning in the wind instruments.

Finally, the authors conclude that the intelligent usage of the tuning standard requires consideration of programming materials and instrumentation; adequate warm-up time of  instruments; careful tuning adjustments and practice at the same temperature as the performance; tuning of not just one note, but several representative notes of the instrument, awareness of the effect of change in temperature on different instruments; and above all the development of the musical understanding and ability of the individual to cope with the ever-changing problems of the wind instrument ensemble.

The artist’s role in bringing forth beautiful music must constantly wrestle with physical anomalies and rely on an internal sense of memory and imagination for what is the desired result.  At our music school in Dallas, Texas we help students gain that internal compass they can lean upon in their artistic and musical pursuits.