The following contains excerpts from the book, The Agony of Modern Music (Henry Pleasants).
This book, first published in 1955, by Pleasants, a former music critic for the Philadelphia
Evening Bulletin (and interestingly a spy for the CIA during the Cold War), chronicles the separation that grew ever wider between contemporary classical composers from the beginning of the 20th Century to the mid-20th Century with their audience, transitioning from a place of cultural prominence to one of being culturally side-lined. His ending conclusion is that jazz has replaced classical music as the primary musical language of the current (1950’s) culture, primarily due to its improvisational nature and cultural relevance.
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we believe it is important to teach students core competencies that emanate from Classical disciplines to use in any style of music the student has a desire to pursue.
Bear in mind that this scenario has also changed over the last 60 years, in which jazz has been replaced by Rock, and Rock now is being replaced by Electronica.
As I consider myself to be a composer, and one who uses techniques from Classical music’s influence, I found this book to be difficult (and somewhat painful) to read, and that’s why it has been sitting on my bookshelf for a number of years before I had the courage to work my way through it.
The book met with immediate resistance when it first came out, and, in the author’s preface, he makes the disclaimer, “I would like, however, to clarify one point raised repeatedly by hostile reviewers when this book first appeared in 1955. This is the possible inference that I equate popularity with quality. I do not. But I do believe that wide acceptance of a style or idiom is proof of its cultural vitality, regardless of its quality…Generally speaking, it seems safe to observe that the most reliable criterion of quality is survival in the affection and esteem of succeeding generations- in other words, in the capacity of a given piece of music to appeal to more than the fallible fashions of a single year or a single generation.”
Regardless of popularity of a style, an artist can have personal integrity. Theat integrity comes from having a deep knowledge of music history and the techniques that have been handed down through the centuries for musicians throughout the Western culture. These are the techniques and skills we teach students at our music school in Dallas, Texas.
The author boldly opens the first chapter with, “Serious music is a dead art. The vein which for three hundred years offered a seemingly inexhaustible yield of beautiful music has run out. What we know as modern music is the noise made by deluded speculators picking through the slagpile…the last really modern serious composer, modern in the sense that he spoke with the full authority of the cultural forces of his time, was Wagner. (1890)” He goes on to say, “The serious composer has lost touch with the currents of popular taste…It is his failure to meet contemporary requirement that distinguishes the contemporary composer from composers of any earlier epoch…Haydn, Handel, Mozart, Beethoven, Chopin, Verdi, Wagner, Brahms, Strauss, and even the early Stravinsky were all popular composers. There was a demand for their music, and they could make a living from accommodating the demand. This is not the case today.”
It is true that the modernist composer of the 20th century saw a growing divide between his art and the audience. In recent times (21st Century) there has been a successful body of thought which has coalesced around answers to questions composers were raising in the mid-twentieth century. At our music school in Dallas, Texas we believe we have come to a place that can help the contemporary creator navigate successfully into the future.
In the chapter, ‘The Composer and Society’, the author writes, “In short, the composer would like to please, but is not pleased to write what pleases society, or at least that part of society which comprises his audience. Society would like to please the composer, whom it regards as an ornament and as a comforting guarantee of cultural continuity, but it is not pleased by what he writes. The situation is tolerated only because both composer and society have been persuaded to believe that this is the way it has always been.”
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we understand that many times the ideas of contemporary music are beyond the reach of the modern audience. However, we teach that the successful musician knows how to stretch the boundaries of an audience’s sensibilities without losing the trust of the audience.
He goes on, in the chapter, ‘The Composer and His Audience’, “It rarely occurs to the contemporary composer that the blame for his estrangement from the serious music audience might lie with himself. He finds it difficult to admit that he is simply not producing anything that provokes a sympathetic response in his listeners…instead he blames the audience…It is not that the contemporary composer does not know his audience. As Copland has said, “There is no disagreement as to what audiences want; they want what they already know, or something that sounds like it.” But now, unlike the situation in Haydn’s time, there is a difference of taste between composer and public. What pleases the public does not please the composer. Finding little sympathy from his audience, the composer turns to his colleagues for comfort, forming a society of musical snobs.”
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we believe that music is more than sound, it is relationships. It is the composer’s responsibility to be empathetic enough with his audience that he knows how far to push the boundaries in his artistic language. Indeed, a relationship takes two parties to find a place of agreement, otherwise there is no relationship – and therefore, no music.
We encourage students in our music school in Dallas, Texas to study history, being immersed in the disciplines that can be learned from past examples. If one does not know the past, he cannot navigate the future successfully. However, we also encourage our students not to live in the past, but to recycle the lessons learned into new areas of current artistic language, and to be listening well enough to the culture to understand how to lead the audience forward without losing them.