Microtonal Pitch Notation

The following contains excerpts from the document, The Extended Helmholtz-Ellis JI Pitch Notation (Marc Sabat).

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach students the value of understanding more than just the equal-tempered scale.  Having a comprehensive view to pitch and pitch-notation along with the historical foundation of pitch-structure helps the student appreciate how pitch can be graded and used in a way that increases the artistic palette.

The intent of this book is to develop a workable solution to the notation of non-standard pitches which deviate from the Equal-Tempered System, originally derived in the 16th Century by J.S. Bach (a system which is now embraced by all Western music, including styles popular in our modern culture).  The need to create a system of notation for tones outside this traditional system, to include microtones, has now become historically necessary.  In order to do this, the author sets forth a procedure that uses the current system of Western notation, adding new markings extending from the traditional ones, to reflect the notes outside the traditional Western scale.

We teach students at our music school in Dallas, Texas the foundational elements of music notation and successful music-reading/sight-reading skills.  To augment that development, we encourage them to expand their understanding of not only the capability of music notation, but also of the possible spectrum of frequencies available to access in a meaningful manner.

The author begins by quoting from famous composer Arnold Schoenberg, “The overtone series…still contains many problems that will have to be faced.  And if for the time being we still manage to escape those problems, it is due to little else than a compromise between the natural intervals and our inability to use them- that compromise which we call the tempered system, which amounts to an indefinitely extended truce.  This reduction of the natural relations to manageable ones cannot permanently impede the evolution of music; and the ear will have to attack the problems, because it is so disposed.  Then our scale will be transformed into a higher order, as the church modes were transformed into major and minor modes.  Whether there will then be quarter tones, eighth, third, or (as Busoni thinks) sixth tones, or whether we will move directly to a 53-tone scale…we cannot foretell.  Perhaps this new division of the octave will even be un-tempered and will not have much left over in common with our scale.”  (Theory of Harmony, 1922)

In our current day of technological advances, the ability to access the overtone series in specific and usable ways has become available.  Schoenberg did not have this opportunity and could only envision the possibility of the existence of usable frequencies beyond the equal-tempered scale.  In his own experimentation, such as with sprechstimme, he sought to go beyond the available equal-tempered tuning system.   Today, however, we have the capability of easily using hundreds of microtonal scales, as well as new uses of the overtone series in application.  At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach composition students how to use digital audio workstations (DAWs) in applying these capabilities.

The author states about his own work, “The Extended Helmholtz-Ellis JI Pitch Notation enables exact notation of all intervals that may be tuned directly by ear (natural intervals).  It provides a method of writing and pitch-height in the glissando-continuum as a note on the five-line staff, and of specifying, in the case of any natural interval, the harmonic relationship by which this note may be precisely tuned.”

He begins by providing definitions of pitch-height, frequency ratios, natural intervals, primary natural intervals, region of tolerance, and comprehensibility.

He then describes the notation system in two ways to describe intervals: linear and proportional, drawing upon Hermann von Helmholtz and Alexander Ellis’ methods of measuring intervals by cents.

He shows charts of the new system, categorizing Pythagorean Intervals, Ptolemaic Intervals, 7-limit (Septimal) Intervals, 11-limit (Unidecimal) Intervals, 13-limit (Tridecimal) Intervals, Primes in the Harmonic Series Octave 16-32, Primes in the Harmonic Series Octave 32-64, and Irrational and Tempered Intervals, all using his new system of notation.

This is a useful system for notating microtonal frequencies for the modern-day composer and the thoroughness of this work is helpful to music creation moving forward.  We encourage composition students at our music school in Dallas, Texas to study and use this system in their forefront creativity.

On a personal note, I have been doing my own research on this subject for a number of years, and was surprised to find that Marc Sabat (a friend of mine from Ivan Glamian’s Meadowmount Summer Camp, when we were both about the age of 13) has done this much successful work on the subject.  It is the future of music, but up to this point has been completely uncharted territory and will most likely be misunderstood and disdained by popular culture for decades.  Even serious-minded contemporary composers find this subject difficult to understand and even more difficult to listen to.  I believe, however, it is a road that must be travelled by the brave creators of our modern era.

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we encourage composition students to understand the value of exploring new areas of pitch and frequency use in avant garde composition.

In my own work, I have discovered ways of using the Overtone Series in ways that can unite multiple musical styles, histories, and disciplines.  This unified system of using the Overtone Series can be seen as a comprehensive system to unite in one ‘scale’ tempo, rhythm, traditional bass-lines and harmonic structure, diatonicism, chromaticism/serialism, microtonality, and spectralism.  This is all accomplished by seeing pitch and rhythm as one system, dropping the fundamental pitch of the Overtone Series being used down multiple octaves below human hearing, where it becomes ‘beat’ or rhythm.  In this manner, it becomes possible to unite all of the above elements successfully in one musical palette.

I accomplished this by building my own synthesizer using Max/MSP in Ableton Live as a DAW.  I was able to build a “Circle of Fifths” using the Overtone Series itself, along with multiple octaves of 30-note overtone series scales.  Thinking of the system like various branches off the same tree trunk, modulation of both pitch and tempo creates a new approach to composition.

I have called this Integrated Frequency.

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we hope to inspire forefront creativity in our students, which includes a comprehensive understanding of the use of frequency in music production and creation.