The following contains excerpts from the book, Early Jazz (Its Roots and Musical Development) (Gunther Schuller).
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we believe that music is more than sound, it is relationships. One of the most important relationships a musician can nurture is one with the fabric of history in which he creates.
“Despite the fact that many ‘serious’ composers and performers had indicated their high regard for jazz as early as the 1920s, the academic credentials of jazz were hardly sufficient to produce a serious interest in the analysis of its techniques and actual musical content…In a sense this book is an answer in terms of specific musical detail to a series of interrelated questions: What makes jazz work? What makes jazz different form other music? Why do so many people find jazz exciting? How did it get that way?…In this respect the book is directed particularly to the ‘classically’ trained musician or composer.”
This is quite possibly one of the top five most important books every musician should know. It has been regarded in the musical community as of paramount importance in the documentation of the jazz style. It is very dense and goes into a good deal of music theory, so I chose to break it into several sections to ensure that I thoroughly understood what the author was saying.”
We teach students at our music school in Dallas, Texas the fundamental ‘core’ competencies they will utilize in any style of music, including Jazz – things like scales, foundational theory, tone quality, and music notation.
Following are the main points in this book:
- “In looking back over more than forty years of his career, we can only marvel at the consistency with which Ellington and his orchestra have sustained a level of inspiration comparable in its way to that of the major ‘classical’ composers of our century.”
- “When Ellington first settled in New York, he came under the influence of Willie ‘the Lion’ Smith and James P. Johnson, whose Carolina Shout he had memorized from a piano roll while he was in Washington. The influence of this Harlem piano style marked all of Ellington’s early orchestral work.”
- “Rhythmic unanimity and collective swing were not a strong point of the Ellington organization until bassist Jimmy Blanton joined the band in 1939.”
- “Many colored bands of the time had two kinds of music in their repertoire, one for Harlem (uptown) and another from Broadway (downtown). If a rough generalization can be made, one can say that the New York bands, small and large, were showy, ‘dicty’ outfits that catered primarily to white audiences and were slow to shake off the trappings of ragtime…Bubber Miley was largely responsible for the initial steps through his introduction of a rougher sound into the band….He helped teach the same techniques to the band’s trombonist – Charlie Irvis and his replacement in late 1926, Joe ‘Tricky Sam’ Nanton…It was Miley and Nanton who developed the band’s famous ‘jungle’ effects through their use of the growl and plunger.”
- “It is a mark of his talent and vision as a leader that in these early days of his band, while he was learning to use the materials he had in hand, he let his musicians lead the way in forming the band’s style. It is evident both from the recordings and also from the statements of contemporary musicians that Ellington was very dependent upon his players at this stage, and that they knew it.”
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we encourage students to play in ensembles with one another. This develops their capacity for learning teamwork and collaboration.
- “Each player was to be chosen by Ellington for some distinctive or unique quality; and it was in 1927 and 1928 – his imagination kindled by Miley and Nanton, and encouraged by the band’s success – that Ellington began to have visions of future possibilities in composition and tonal color…In Birmingham Breakdown, an Ellington composition, he uses for the first time phrases not based on either the thirty-two-bar song form or the various blues forms…these led eventually to the larger asymmetrical formations of Black, Brown, and Beige and other extended works…In Hop Head, and Ellington-Hardwick collaboration, one can hear in embryonic form the arranged brass-ensemble chorus which, with the gradual enlargement of the brass section, became another of the Ellington trademarks.”
- “In the introduction of Got Everything But You and Spencer Williams’s Tishomingo Blues, Ellington experiments with ‘modern’ harmonies…one of the striking characteristics of Ellington’s voice-leading…giving…important notes within the chord that specifically determine the quality of that chord. It is this seemingly minute detail of voicing which adds that unusual, rich, slightly dark, and at times melancholy flavor to Ellington’s saxophone writing.”
We teach composition students at our music school in Dallas, Texas how to orchestrate and arrange in ways that highlight tonal color and voice-leading successfully.
- In Yellow Dog Blues “Ellington superimposes over the three sustained clarinets a short figure that momentarily clashes with them in a very subtle way…the original precursor of a long line of such harmonic clashes, most notably those in Ko-Ko.”
- “Ellington’s process of writing (or of dictating head arrangements to the band) generally encompassed five distinct kinds of tunes or compositions: 1) numbers for dancing; 2) jungle-style and/or production numbers for the Cotton Club; 3) the ‘blue’ or ‘mood’ pieces; 4) pop tunes (at first written by others, later in increasing measure his own); and 5) pieces which, although written for specific occasions, turned out to be simply abstract ‘musical composition.’ (It should go without saying that these categories were not always consciously developed and that some pieces defy exact categorization and could belong to several groups.) And second, within these categories Ellington worked out specific musical ideas – a certain progression , a certain voicing, or a certain scoring – by repeating them in successive arrangements through a process of trial and error until he had found the best solution for the problem. Then he would move on to tackle the next idea or problem.”
- “How did Ellington, at first a musician with a decided leaning toward ‘show music,’ develop into one of America’s foremost composers? It was precisely due to…working five years at the Cotton Club. There, by writing and experimenting with all manner of descriptive production and dance numbers, Ellington’s inherent talent and imagination could develop properly…the need for new background music for constantly changing acts at the Cotton Club in a sense required Ellington to investigate composition (rather than arranging) as a medium of expression, and fortunately he found in his band imaginative musicians who could help him develop and implement his ideas.”
Ellington was empathetic with the band members he led, in such a way as to listen to their ideas and weave them into his compositions. At our music school in Dallas, Texas we encourage our students to listen attentively, and to be inspired by a wide range of ideas to which they are exposed.
- “Although Ellington made some 160 recordings between mid-1928 and mid-1931, all of them interesting, very few were completely successful artistically…But slowly and relentlessly, through a process of continuous reappraisal, of constant polishing and refining, the Duke’s musical concepts began to crystallize…Ellington in 1928 wrote Misty Mornin’ and Awful Sad, both leading up to the immortal Mood Indigo of 1930.”
The process of musical growth and the development of one’s own unique artistic voice can take a lifetime. We encourage students at our music school in Dallas, Texas to be patient with the process and to enjoy the journey.
- “In the production- or show-music category, Ellington produced some two dozen numbers, ranging from such bits of dated exotica as Arabian Lover or its companion piece, Japanese Dream (pentatonic melodies, ominous Chinese gongs and all) to more original pieces, such as Jungle Jamboree and Rocky Mountain Blues…in almost every piece – whether bad or good – Ellington and his men tried to work out some new sound and new musical idea.”
- “In Old Man Blues…the perfect balance between composition and improvisation was achieved. This achievement is, of course, above all else, Ellington’s greatest contribution to the development of jazz…Ellington ‘solved the unbelievably difficult problem of turning a living, shifting and improvised folk-music into composition without losing its spontaneity.”
- “The consolidation of Ellington’s style in the early 1930s coincided with a similar coalescence in jazz in general. Very clearly the early 1930s represented the end of an era as well as the beginning of a new one. The first generation of great jazz artists was passing from the scene…the nation’s social climate was experiencing a drastic reorientation precipitated by the Depression. Likewise, jazz was reaching toward new artistic goals and a broader social acceptance. Sobered and matured by the Wall Street crash and the Depression, the hellion audience of the ganger-ridden ‘jazz age’ gave way to an audience characterized by a more personal, deeper involvement with jazz…Although jazz was still primarily associated with social dancing, a significant minority of jazz buffs, who regarded jazz as a new art form, was beginning to emerge…by the early 1930s jazz had developed to the point where it had a history of its own and could point to its own traditions.”