The Nature of Music – Part 2

The following contains excerpts from the book, The Nature of Music (Hermann Scherchen).

The author, a conductor in Germany in the 1940’s, wrote the book to show the foundations of Western music and how the technical structure of its organization was used by Bach, then Beethoven to express emotion.  The book is divided up into three basic sections: 1) The study of the French physicist, Sauveur, who gave music the scientific basis for what we now take for granted as the Equal-Tempered Scale, 2) How J.S. Bach used and maximized this new Scale to his artistic advantages, and 3) How Beethoven took the aforementioned tradition to a new level of emotional expression.

The second and third sections of the book are theoretical analyses of a number of Bach’s and Beethoven’s works, as well as quite a bit of subjectivity, which I found to be conjectural at best.  The most exciting part of the book was his explanation of how the scale and its harmonic use in our current culture, known as Equal-Temperament, came into being.

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach students about the various tuning systems that have been developed in Western culture.

Modern musical theory begins with this limitation of the apparently boundless field of harmonic variation to a few types of chords.  Sauveur realized that even the ablest musicians could not remain within the bounds of a purely diatonic system, and that they ultimately are forced to apply slight corrections to its intervals.  The difficulties of applying a purely diatonic system made it necessary for Sauveur to establish a form of equal temperament, a system that would contain the best of all possible temperaments.  He writes, “A tempered system should simplify the theoretical side of tonality.  The octave should not be divided into too many notes, and the pure diatonic intervals should be altered as little as possible.”

One of the first lessons a student in our music school in Dallas, Texas will learn is how to identify and form an octave.

What he finally settled on as his own preference was a temperament in 43 degrees.  Sauveur comments on the system of twelve equally tempered notes, in use even now, “This system is preferred by our less competent instrumentalists; it allows one to transpose easily without changing of interval.  But more sensitive musicians have rejected it, because its intervals deviate from the natural diatonic norm.”

Sauveur, standardized exact frequencies for given notes, taking the note-name ‘C’, for example, and assigning it the frequency of 256 cycles per second, which is derived from multiples of two: 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, 64, 128, 256.

He also proved that, by exact determination of the pitch of any substance, its relative and absolute weight may be deduced (i.e. the mine shafts).  “By the same means it is possible to discover the rate of vibration of the vocal chords during singing, and of the lips when blowing instruments or whistling.  All the natural frequencies of bodies sounding in resonance with them (i.e. sound-boards, vases and cavities in the human body), and even the scarcely perceptible micro-intervals of bird-song can equally be determined.”

Sauveur’s determination of pitch made the concept of a ‘key’ a practical reality.  J.S. Bach was one of the first to apply keys according to their fixed character.  In 1725 he published the first part of ‘The Well-Tempered Clavier’, which goes twice through each of the major and minor keys.

We encourage students at our music school in Dallas, Texas to study J.S. Bach’s works, and to appreciate the historical significance of his use of Equal-Temperament.

Sauveur’s experiments also aided Rameau’s inspired conception of the ‘chord’ as an aurally perceptible imitation of a natural phenomenon, which he writes about in his ‘Traite de l’Harmonie’ (1722), developing the concept of inversions of chords.  The understanding that the ‘fundamental’ (a term first coined by Sauveur) is the foundation of chordal harmony, and that harmony is based upon the harmonic series of that fundamental, completely reversed the conception of music which had been accepted for more than a thousand years.

It could now be confirmed that:

  1. The ‘fundamental’ supplies energy to all other notes
  1. Basic harmony relates all other chords to itself
  1. Single notes- the fixed points of polyphony- seem to give the impetus to a new kind of part-writing

All tonal structure could now be explained as harmonic movement around a center, which integrates even the most distant chordal formations and harmonies.

There are still new revelations that can have a direct application to our understanding of music by studying the Overtone Series.  We teach students at our music school in Dallas, Texas new possibilities of its use.

“Although Sauveur died too early to receive the title of ‘The Newton of Acoustics’, his contemporaries soon named Rameau ‘The Newton of Harmony’.  For the first time a musical reformer was also the theoretician of his own reforms.”

Simon Sechter- with whom Schubert was planning to study counterpoint in 1827, continued to teach by Rameau’s rules until 1850.  And Anton Bruchner (1824-1896), a pupil of Sechter, took over from him Rameau’s ‘Manual of Thoroughbass’ and his doctrine of Chromatic chords derived from double roots.  Rameau’s ‘Construction of chords by thirds’ is still in use today.  (This concept actually became the basis for modern Jazz theory.)

We teach students in our music school in Dallas, Texas how to analyze Jazz harmonies based on the re-ordering of thirds.

Summing up, from the introduction to the book, Scherchen writes,

“Sauveur, a French physicist who was deaf and dumb from birth laid the foundations of acoustics in 1700.  In 1750, J.S. Bach, then blind, dictated his finest composition; and in 1800, Beethoven, already on the way to incurable deafness, felt the inward call to transform the sounds of music into a spiritual language.  It is extraordinary that a deaf mute should have discovered the scientific basis of music, that a blind and dying man should be the first to proclaim the mysteries of its creation, while a third, also deaf, should have given it an added emotional power.”

The very basis of the music we hear today, from Pop/Rock to Jazz or Classical (and everything in-between) is firmly set upon the Equal-Tempered scale.  This system has now become the standard upon which every electronic keyboard and music software program is built, globally.  To hear anything different than this would sound strange to our Western ears.  There was a time in history when it was so new that Equal-Temperament itself took some ‘getting used to’.   

As wonderful as Equal-Temperament is, and with all the fruit it has yielded it is still, in essence, a compromised system created to be used by instruments of approximation.  With computer technology, however, and the ability to function fluidly in a variety of Diatonic systems without conflict, we now have the ability to exactly replicate specific frequencies, along with their multiple harmonic series’ in precise combinations.  I believe we are scientifically and aesthetically ready for another ‘shift’ in our approach to music, for the first time in over 300 years.

We are excited to train a new generation in the mysteries of pitch, tuning, and the Overtone Series at our music school in Dallas, Texas.  The future of music is ever evolving and we hope to arm our students with a historical understanding of these subjects, as well as the practical application of them.