The following contains excerpts from the book, The Inside Story of Brass Instruments (Earle Kent).
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we encourage our composition students to understand the acoustical nature of all orchestral instruments, including the brass and woodwind families
This book is a reference guide to brass instruments produced by the Conn manufacturer of brass and woodwind instruments. It covers the scientific method of: 1) understanding brass instruments, and 2) the manufacturing of brass instruments.
By way of introduction, the author asserts, “Musical instruments using cup-shaped mouthpieces appear to be rather straight-forward and simple devices…Scientific studies have proven, however, that the simple theories commonly accepted as explaining tone production in this group of instruments are inadequate; that many complexities exist; and that many facts entering into the problem are still unknown.”
Nevertheless, certain aspects are known, and that is what is highlighted in the book. The three basic elements of brass instruments are: 1) it furnishes the musician with an intonation guide; 2) it serves to couple or project the sound produced by the lips to free space outside the instrument in an efficient manner, and 3) it alters or augments the quality of the sounds produced by the lips of the musician to make them more artistically pleasing.
Tone production is a subject that requires a deep understanding of both aesthetics and acoustics. At our music school in Dallas, Texas we emphasize both.
The nature of a brass instrument is determined by its ‘resonance’. It is the bell of the instrument that reflects frequencies back into the instrument itself, which causes it to be centered on a particular scale derived from the overtone series. “The horns on loud-speakers are designed to produce as little resonance as practicable because their function is to project sounds of all frequencies equally well. In the case of cup-mouthpiece instruments, it is desired to project only the frequencies in the scale of the instrument and the multiples of these frequencies.”
Understanding resonance is critical for the student who wants to produce beautiful music, and at our music school in Dallas, Texas our teachers help students develop a perception and appreciation for this subject.
The frequencies at which the instrument resonates depends on: 1) the physical length of the air column (the distance the sound has to travel in the instrument); 2) the speed at which the sound travels through the instrument, and 3) the shape, or calibration, or the bore of the instrument. When the distance is lengthened (by pulling the tuning slide), the resonant frequencies go ‘flat’. When the distance is shortened, the resonant frequencies go ‘sharp’. Because sound travels slower in cool air, when cool air is played through the instrument, it will sound ‘flat’ and conversely, as sound travels faster in warm air, when warm air is played through the instrument, it sounds ‘sharp’.
The cylinder of a brass instrument, when the bore is properly calibrated, can be made to ‘naturally’ play very closely to whatever tuning system is desired (Equal-Tempered or Just). Adding valves gives the player the ability to produce the tones of a complete musical scale, and not just tones based on the overtone series. Valves, however, introduce certain ‘discrepancies’ of intonation, particularly with instruments that are not perfectly designed. To compensate, many instruments make provision for the musician to alter the valve slide lengths with a finger-ring.
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach students a variety of tuning systems, particularly those related to the Overtone Series and Equal Temperament.
The book goes on to describe the importance of various factors in manufacturing instruments that function successfully. Issues such as coupling (the ‘amplification’ of the tones made by the lips), tone production, harmonic alignment, bell size and the mouth-piece all influence the quality of the resonance and intonation of the instrument.
The author cites some unusual problems with what he calls ‘acoustical overload’: “One of the factors within the instrument is the acoustical overload that takes place when sounds of high intensity travel through the instrument. This comes about because sound is a compressional wave and air is not a perfect transmitter of compressional waves of high intensity. Air does not behave as a perfect spring which deforms the same amount when the same force is applied whether in compression or in tension. This causes what is known as a non-linear effect, or distortion. If two or more tones were mixed together and subjected to this distortion in a loud speaker, it would be unbearable. But when it happens to a single tone in, for example a trumpet, we say the tone is “brighter,” more “brassy,” or the like. This overloading of the air column is at least part of the reason that tones produced at loud volumes on brass instruments are ‘brighter’ than tones played at soft volumes.”
The art of orchestration in composition and arranging requires the creator to understand nuances of tone production, such as what was described in the preceding paragraph. At our music school in Dallas, Texas we help our composition students experience many anomalies such as this, to broaden their capacity to write for a wide range of instruments.
The history and development of brass instruments is interesting and is continuing to move forward in future developments. Understanding these basic principles not only helps in relating to brass and wind players, but also deepens an appreciation for the complexities of sound in general.
It is our goal at our music school in Dallas, Texas to expose the composer/arranger to as much information along these lines as possible to equip them for successful work.
Even though much music creativity has moved from acoustic to electronic, there are still significant correlations between the two areas of work. Having an understanding of musical acoustics can help the electronic musician be informed about how to use specific wave-forms to meet their aesthetic desires in ways that seem ‘natural.’
In addition to that, in Subtractive synthesis, the idea of resonation is particularly affected by similar frequency manipulations.