The Nature of Music – Part 1
The following contains excerpts from the book, The Nature of Music (Hermann Scherchen).
The author, a conductor in Germany in the 1940’s, wrote the book to show the foundations of Western music and how the technical structure of its organization was used by Bach, then Beethoven to express emotion. The book is divided up into three basic sections: 1) The study of the French physicist, Sauveur, who gave music the scientific basis for what we now take for granted as the Equal-Tempered Scale, 2) How J.S. Bach used and maximized this new Scale to his artistic advantages, and 3) How Beethoven took the aforementioned tradition to a new level of emotional expression.
The second and third sections of the book are theoretical analyses of a number of Bach’s and Beethoven’s works, as well as quite a bit of subjectivity, which I found to be conjectural at best. The most exciting part of the book was his explanation of how the scale and its harmonic use in our current culture, known as Equal-Temperament, came into being.
At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach students about the various tuning systems that have been developed in Western culture.
The author states, “Music owes to Joseph Sauveur three discoveries which proved more fruitful than any previously known to acoustics. They were: the method of determining the pitch of a note by assessing the frequency of its vibrations, the investigation of the nature of musical sound, and the systematic establishment of a tempered scale.”
Interestingly, Sauveur was born deaf and dumb. He never obtained full mastery over his voice and his faulty hearing denied him enjoyment of his own acoustical observations. He wrote, in his ‘Harmonie Universelle’ (1636-7), “Even a deaf man, if he knows the length and thickness of a string, can tune the lute, viol, spinet and all other stringed instrument and find any note on them.” In this treatise, his experiments in frequency yielded the following conclusions:
- Length- The frequency of vibration of a stretched string varies inversely with its length.
- Volume- The frequency of vibration varies inversely with the diameter of other strings of the same material. Where the material is different, the frequency varies inversely with the square root of
- the mass of string per unit of length.
- Tension of String- The frequency of vibration is in direct proportion to the square root of the force of tension.
For the simplest vibration (the fundamental frequency) of a stretched string, the following formula is given, where F= frequency of vibration, L= length, x= tension, and m= mass per cm of string.
“Sauveur laid the foundations of acoustics through his method of determining the pitch of a note by indirect means. At last, a scientific approach provided music with a firm basis. The construction of instruments, the sound capacity of rooms, and in fact the entire mechanical aspect of acoustics now achieved basic principles calculable by algebraical formulae.”
Sauveur’s simplification of acoustical nomenclature emanated only from vibrations. He saw sound as a process of recurrent vibrations. He realized the correlation between pitch and rate of vibration, and also of the intensity of sound and amplitude of vibration.
We help students at our music school in Dallas, Texas appreciate how frequency (Hz) and pitch are synonymous.
He was the first to realize the limitation of pitch perception, showing that human’s ears are not sensitive enough to recognize the smallest intervals (space between notes). The octave can be divided into 43 sections, of which each can be subdivided into 7 further sub-sections, giving a total of 301 sub-sections. (In other words, instead of our current system of 12 notes in an octave, there would be 301!) As humans, we are not capable of differentiating at that degree of accuracy.
So Sauveur’s life-goal, at that point was to develop, in his own words, “A comprehensive system of intervals and its bearing on all systems of music and musical instruments,” which was the subject of his ‘Memoire’ of 1701. In the introduction of ‘Memoire’, Sauveur points out that all musical theory adapts itself to the changes of contemporary taste. He asks in his thesis for a comprehensive science of sound in which music is only an isolated case of acoustic phenomena.
One of the most important lessons for the music student to learn is to identify intervals, that is, the space between two notes. At our music school in Dallas, Texas we train our students to hear various intervallic relationships.
What he ultimately developed was the concept of a fixed pitch being independent of time and space. Every musical composition could now be played anywhere at exactly the same pitch. Until that time in history, fixed pitch was non-standardized.
Sauveur was aware that the principle of overtones was of central importance in acoustics and music, writing, “I use the term harmonic for the sound which completes several vibrations while the fundamental completes one.” He wanted to demonstrate the principle of overtones visibly as well as audibly, so he took the fundamental as the reference point.
The value of understanding the Overtone Series cannot be overstated, and we teach students at our music school in Dallas, Texas how to understand its basic construct.
Sauveur’s predecessors viewed notes of a scale derived from these ratios: 1:2 (octave) 2:3 (fifth) 3:4 (fourth) 4:5 (major third) 5:6 (minor third) 3:5 (major sixth 5:8 (minor sixth), etc. Sauveur changed this, however, where the sequence of notes was represented proportionally, in relation a basic unity: 1:2 (octave) 1:3 (twelfth, or fifth) 1:4 (fifteenth) 1:5 (seventeenth, or third). At the same time he showed the principle of harmonic notes. The conclusions drawn at the end of ‘Memoire’ are as follows:
- In Music- the natural frequency of all sounding bodies may be readily measured
- In Physiology- the perceptory limits of the human ear may be exactly determined for high as well as low notes.
- In the Mathematics of Acoustics- the air displaced by a vibrating string can also be determined.
- In Physics- changes of natural frequency in a sounding body give some indication of the condition of its substance.
He discovered that increase in the pressure on a compressed body raises its pitch when struck. The realization of this fact, since his discovery, has actually saved human life: miners knock on the wooden part of the roof when they enter a shaft and estimate the pressure of the mountain above. If the pitch is found to rise quickly, the roof has to be strengthened.
Ultimately, Sauveur’s experimentation was for the purpose of musical application, so he abandoned his original intention of establishing a general system of sound, to return to pursuing a system in which music became the particular goal.
In our modern day, forefront science understands the universe as vibrating strands of energy. At our music school in Dallas, Texas we help students to appreciate the relationship of music to all frequency studies.
The scales we teach students at our music school in Dallas, Texas are rooted in Equal-Temperament; however, we help them understand that there are times in which other tuning systems are appropriate.