Early Jazz (Its Roots and Musical Development – Part 7

The following contains excerpts from the book, Early Jazz (Its Roots and Musical Development) (Gunther Schuller).

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we believe that music is more than sound, it is relationships.  One of the most important relationships a musician can nurture is one with the fabric of history in which he creates.

“Despite the fact that many ‘serious’ composers and performers had indicated their high regard for jazz as early as the 1920s, the academic credentials of jazz were hardly sufficient to produce a serious interest in the analysis of its techniques and actual musical content…In a sense this book is an answer in terms of specific musical detail to a series of interrelated questions: What makes jazz work? What makes jazz different form other music? Why do so many people find jazz exciting? How did it get that way?…In this respect the book is directed particularly to the ‘classically’ trained musician or composer.”

This is quite possibly one of the top five most important books every musician should know.  It has been regarded in the musical community as of paramount importance in the documentation of the jazz style.  It is very dense and goes into a good deal of music theory, so I chose to break it into several sections to ensure that I thoroughly understood what the author was saying.”

We teach students at our music school in Dallas, Texas the fundamental ‘core’ competencies they will utilize in any style of music, including Jazz – things like scales, foundational theory, tone quality, and music notation.

Following are the main points in this book:

  1. “In the early decades of jazz, the average ensemble consisted of five or six players, usually the front-line trinity of clarinet, trumpet, and trombone, with piano, drums, and bass added…ensembles which frequently had a violinist as leader or an extra saxophone or two…a basically improvised music…obvious that the musical result could be better controlled with five players than with ten, unless unusual safeguards were imposed.”
  1. “By the mid- and late thirties, at the height of the Swing Era, when the fourteen-man big band had become a jazz institution, the music it played featured almost exclusively block chords, homophonic section writing, and parallel voicings.”

At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach our students the value of ‘strong lines,’ particularly when it comes to homophonic section lines against other contrapuntal elements.

  1. “Back in the twenties, the road leading to a significant orchestral conception in jazz was just in its blueprint stages…there was a new breed of jazz musician entering the field.  He belonged to a younger generation, born around 1900, and was likely to be well educated, perhaps even a college graduate, partly brought up in the North, and capable of going on to one of the professions: in other words, a member of the rising Negro middle class.  These men were often schooled musicians, and, unlike most of their New Orleans forebears who regarded music as an avocation, they saw jazz as a profession, and one, moreover, with potential financial rewards…This new breed was typified by Fletcher Henderson, (with a degree in chemistry), Don Redman (a conservatory graduate), Duke Ellington, Coleman Hawkins, Buster Baily, and Walter Page, all with some degree of musical education.  Many others could read music or had enough formal background to pick it up if needed…a cross-fertilization thus began between the reading, non-improvising, instrumentally schooled musician, and his less literate, though not necessarily less gifted, counterpart.”

The value of comprehensive training in core conditioning is invaluable to all musicians, and at our music school in Dallas, Texas we help students of all backgrounds and capabilities develop in these disciplines.

  1. “In New York, Fletcher Henderson’s orchestra was for many years the most influential jazz organization.  Under Henderson’s leadership, but more importantly, through the arranging abilities of Don Redman, the orchestra successfully developed a formula for employing a larger ensemble in an essentially homophonic style that could incorporate a true jazz solo.”
  1. “The music that dominated the decade prior to the arrival of men like Henderson and Ellington was that of a Negro musician by the name of James Reese Europe.  Europe’s fame rested largely upon his association with the popular ballroom dance team of Irene and Vernon Castle, for whom he provided the music.  Out of their collaboration came the foxtrot and many other popular steps that had a major part in initiating the Jazz Age…This music was relentlessly rhythmic and, for all its repetitiousness, somehow not monotonous….though it was referred to as ‘syncopated music’ (and Europe’s various groups were officially called ‘syncopated orchestras’), there is considerably less syncopation in these performances than one might expect.  The pieces were usually in lively 2/4 tempos (usually around quarter = 140) with melodies that can best be described as simplified, smoothed-out ragtime tunes…The music had a rough excitement and rhythmic momentum that simply carried its audience along physically…James Europe was the most important transitional figure in the pre-history of jazz on the East Coast…In some ways Europe was to orchestral jazz the same kind of catalyst Jelly Roll Morton was for piano music.  Both added new rhythmic dimensions to ragtime and prepared the way for the full emergence of jazz.”
  1. “Fletcher Henderson’s…musical background was oriented more toward light ‘classical’ music than toward jazz.  He had studied piano with his mother, a ‘classically’ – trained pianist, and the Hendersons were one of those middle-class Negro families who disapproved of jazz and other ‘low-down’ music like the blues…He was not a leader in the sense that Duke Ellington was, or Morton, or even Armstrong.  The creative stylistic stimulus did not radiate from him, but rather from his men and most particularly from his chief arranger Don Redman.  Henderson did have a keen sense for hiring a certain kind of talented but disciplined player who fitted into his conception of jazz – neat, clean, well-balanced, and somewhat uninvolved emotionally.”

In the above example of Fletcher Henderson, we again see the value of Classical music’s influence on early Jazz.  The core training he received at an early age set him up for high artistic achievement as he bridged into other styles.  This is why we teach these disciplines in our music school in Dallas, Texas.

  1. “Don Redman…had been a child prodigy and a conservatory-trained musician who was able to play almost all the conventional instruments and who had already done some arranging for a band from Pittsburgh…With the arrival of Louis Armstrong as a featured soloist, Redman had to find the proper stylistic frame for this startling soloist’s work…Redman’s…solution was based on the intuitive recognition of the fact that Louis, who was in a transitional stage at this time, was still close enough to the New Orleans collective ensemble technique to permit a bridge between it and the newer solo-and-section style.  Copenhagen was Redman’s brilliant realization of this intuition….Redman stressed the contrast between brass and reeds in an unequivocal way.  Brass trios were contrasted with clarinet trios, and the separation of choirs was emphasized by writing parallel sections that contrasted with collective improvisations when the choirs were mixed.”

Here, again, is an example of a Classically trained musician, who had a substantial influence on Jazz.  The value of learning Classical music cannot be overstated, regardless of which stylistic direction the creative artist pursues.  At our music school in Dallas, Texas we teach these disciplines thoroughly and methodically.

  1. “The Southwest was second only to the Midwest in its passion for concert bands, the most famous of which were Sousa’s and Pryor’s, the latter specializing in band versions of cakewalk and ragtime pieces…In addition…the blues had always had strong roots in the Southwest, for many of the best-known early itinerant blues singers were born and raised in Texas, Oklahoma, and Arkansas.”
  2. “By 1923 Bennie Moten had the most popular band in Kansas City…By 1924 the Moten orchestra had increased to a personnel of eight by adding a tuba and the Kansas City saxophone player (and later leader) Harlan Leonard…The recordings of this period are manifestly excellent dance music, and one can readily understand why Moten’s band, with its rocking beat, was the most popular in the territory…New Tulsa Blues draws heavily for its earthy rocking beat on the boogie-woogie piano style that was spreading like wildfire throughout the Southwest.”
  1. “The two bands that gave Moten his biggest competition were Alphonse Trent’s and Walter Page’s Blue Devils…By 1928, Trent had enlarged his orchestra to twelve (the size of Henderson’s)…Nightmare and Black and Blue Rhapsody…had a firmly established style…a remarkable polish.”
  1. “The Wall Street crash was beginning to take its toll on the music business.  The whole big-band business was in a state of economic flux.  There were now hundreds of large and small bands, all competing for the dwindling financial market.  Many of them collapsed in the early thirties, sometimes because of a lack of bookings or because of dishonest agents.  Other bands lost their star personnel and were unable to survive in the highly competitive field.  Some were fortunate in finding equal or better replacements.  Still other orchestras fled to Europe for a while, as did Ellington in 1932.  And curiously, some bands survived the Depression reasonably well, while others like Andy Kirk’s Twelve Clouds of Joy, the Jimmie Lunceford band, and a number of Southwestern orchestras actually began life during the early Depression years…It is difficult today to comprehend how many excellent orchestras there were.  Most of them never recorded, some few recorded a handful of sides on lesser labels.”
  1. “On that…day in Camden in 1932, the Moten band not only cut ten sides which can only be described in superlatives, but inaugurated a conception of orchestral jazz distinct from that of Henderson and the Eastern axis, a conception moreover which was to bypass the inherent stylistic hazards of the Swing Era and provide at least one of the routes leading to modern jazz and bop.  Musicians who played in the Moten band on that date recall that their tour had been a financial disaster, and they reached Camden broke and hungry.  Hearing the exuberant abandon and joyousness of these recordings, one would never guess such conditions…The two main arrangers, Eddie Barefield and Eddie Durham, contributed strongly, but their arrangements came to life in the hands of the major soloists – Hot Lips Page, Ben Webster, Basie – and the extraordinary rhythm section…perhaps the most consistently thrilling …are Toby, Blue Room, Prince of Wales, Lafayette…Count Basie’s…abilities here can be sampled on Toby (at a breakneck speed of quarter = 340) and on his special number Prince of Wales.  These recordings produced a rhythmic revolution comparable to Armstrong’s earlier one.  They spelled the doom of all earlier rhythm-section techniques.  They also contained the seeds for a process of total liberation for each of the four rhythm instruments, a process that was to reach another conceptual plateau ten years later in the beginnings of the Bop Era…Moten’s band developed from a rough novelty-cum-ragtime band to one of the great orchestras of jazz…somewhat gropingly and erratically Moten’s band accumulated its language bit by bit.”